+44 (0)1604 968 820
eCommerce Insights

Is January Really the Best Time to Start Your New 3PL Search?

Originally Published: 16 November 2026

Last Updated: 16 November 2026

J&J Global Fulfilment J&J Global Fulfilment
Is January Really the Best Time to Start Your New 3PL Search?

November and December are the busiest months of the year for many eCommerce brands. There’s Peak, Black Friday, Christmas, and everything that comes with them.

If you’re fulfilling in-house, there’s all the planning, forecasting, and resourcing to think about, and that’s before the busy season even begins. Come mid-November, it’s all hands on deck, with little room to breathe as you and your team work around the clock to get orders out on time.

Even if you’re outsourcing fulfilment, there’s still marketing, campaigns, customer service, and everything else that contributes to a successful final quarter.

So, if you’re thinking about finding your first 3PL or switching providers in 2027, it can be tempting to push through Peak and save the time and headspace required for your search until January, when things have calmed down.

But is January really the best time to start looking for a new 3PL?

Why January might not be the best time

The January rush to find a new fulfilment partner is real. At J&J, we see a significant influx of enquiries at the start of every year.

There are a few reasons for this. January is traditionally a time for new beginnings, fresh goals, and setting your business up for a successful year ahead. But crucially, many of the brands that approach us in January do so because their current in-house operation, or their existing 3PL, isn’t working quite as well as it should. And problems are significantly more noticeable during Peak.

The issues with waiting until January are that finding the right 3PL takes time. Naturally, you’ll want to do your due diligence. That means speaking to different providers, comparing quotes, reviewing their capabilities, and ultimately deciding which is the best fit for your business.

We looked at our own data and found that, on average, brands that onboard with J&J take around 60 days to make a decision, with larger brands taking longer. So, if you fall into that average, you’re looking at March or April before you’re even ready to begin onboarding.

And onboarding itself can take time. It’s in a 3PL’s best interest to get you up and running as quickly as possible, but it’s equally important to make sure everything is done correctly.

If you’re a smaller brand with a handful of SKUs and straightforward domestic shipping requirements, onboarding might only take a couple of weeks. But for larger brands with more complex requirements, or those looking to fulfil from multiple locations, the process can take longer.

That’s especially true if you need to take care of everything that sits alongside fulfilment, such as tax registrations, documentation, and other compliance requirements.

Realistically, you could be looking at another 30–60 days before you’re fully onboarded and live with your new 3PL.

2023 11 15 JJ FulfilmentCentre 117

Put those timelines together, and a search that begins in January might not result in your new fulfilment operation going live until May or June.

Suddenly, you’re approaching the second half of the year, with less time than you might like to settle into your new operation before the next Peak. And it’s not just the time it takes to make a decision and go live.

As we’ve already mentioned, 3PLs see a spike in enquiries during January. That increased demand means more brands competing for attention, potentially resulting in slower responses and reduced availability for important stages of the decision-making process, such as proposal reviews, operational discussions, and site visits.

Starting conversations before Christmas means you can get ahead of that rush, rather than joining the queue alongside everyone else in January.

Peak is the perfect time to see what’s going wrong (and right)

You should know fairly early on whether Peak is going well, okay, or downright terribly.

Peak trading starts earlier than ever, with the volume that was once concentrated around Black Friday weekend now spread across a much longer period.

Over the past couple of years, we’ve seen order volumes really begin to spike on the Monday before Black Friday. By the time Black Friday itself rolls around, you’ll probably have a pretty good understanding of how your operation is performing.

That’s useful information if you’re considering a new 3PL. Problems that are relatively easy to dismiss, or perhaps go unnoticed during quieter periods, become much harder to ignore when volumes spike. Misspicks, orders getting stuck, and missed SLAs are all exacerbated when order volumes increase.

Communication becomes more important than ever, too. Does your 3PL proactively keep you informed when something goes wrong, or do they wait for you to discover the problem yourself, potentially when it’s already too late to do anything about it?

Are unexpected costs suddenly mounting up? Are processes that seemed perfectly adequate during quieter months beginning to buckle under the pressure?

These are all things worth documenting during Peak and bringing to the table when you begin speaking to potential 3PL partners before Christmas.

New Year New FC

But it’s just as important to pay attention to what’s going right. Perhaps your current provider handles increased order volumes brilliantly, but struggles with inventory visibility or communication. Maybe their technology is excellent, but their international shipping capabilities are holding back your expansion plans.

Or, if you’re fulfilling in-house, perhaps your team is doing a fantastic job of getting orders out of the door, but it’s becoming increasingly clear that the time, space, and resources required to keep things running are limiting your ability to grow.

Understanding what’s working well is just as valuable as knowing what needs to improve. It gives you a clearer picture of what you should be looking for in your next fulfilment partner, and which capabilities you simply can’t afford to compromise on.

After all, the goal isn’t just to find a different 3PL. It’s to find one that’s better suited to where your business is heading.

Our advice: get the ball rolling before Christmas

We know you’re probably not going to have the time or headspace to begin your 3PL search in earnest before Christmas. After all, we’ve spent much of this article talking about just how busy this time of year can be, and things are unlikely to calm down until the final Christmas orders are out of the door.

But if you’re serious about switching 3PLs in 2027, our advice is simple. Start the conversation before Christmas, even if you’re not ready to start the search properly.

If you’ve been paying attention to what’s worked and what hasn’t during Peak, you’ll already have a good understanding of what you’re looking for in your next fulfilment partner. That puts you in a great position to begin reaching out to potential providers and laying the groundwork for the new year.

The key is not to take on too much, too soon. The last thing you need during Peak is another major project competing for your attention.

Instead, focus on booking a few introductory calls before the Christmas break. Use them to outline your requirements, explain what you’re hoping to achieve, and make it clear that you’re planning to explore your options properly in January.

There’s no need to request detailed proposals, sit through lengthy pitches, or make any commitments just yet. At this stage, it’s simply about making introductions and getting a feel for which providers might be a good fit.

That way, when January rolls around, you’re not starting your search from scratch. You’ve already made contact, established your requirements, and potentially identified a shortlist of providers worth exploring further.

And while other brands are only beginning to reach out to 3PLs, you’ll already be one step ahead.

Interested in touching base with us this side of Christmas? Get in touch today, and we’ll ensure you’re ahead of the pack when the new year comes.